Defensive vs Offensive Mindset

Defensive vs. Offensive Player Mindset in the Era of Offensive Dominance



Hockey, as a dynamic and ever-evolving sport, is currently witnessing a significant shift towards offensive dominance in the NHL. Coaches and players alike are grappling with the need to strike a delicate balance between defensive stability and a proactive offensive mindset. In this article, we explore the contrasting mentalities of defensive-minded and offensive-minded players, emphasizing the importance of adapting to the demands of the modern game.


Defensive Mindset:


Traditionally, coaches have prioritized defensive strategies, ingraining habits such as backchecking, shot blocking, and clearing the front of the net into their players. The defensive mindset revolves around discipline, responsibility, and a commitment to limiting the opposition's scoring opportunities.


Discipline and Positioning:

Defensive-minded players adhere to a disciplined approach, maintaining proper positioning and minimizing defensive breakdowns. Their commitment to staying between opponents and the net forms the foundation of a strong team defensive structure.


Awareness and Readiness:

A heightened awareness of surroundings and quick reactions define the defensive player's mindset. Readiness to intercept passes, block shots, and disrupt the opponent's offensive flow are key components of a successful defensive approach.


Team-first Mentality:

The defensive mindset promotes a team-first mentality, emphasizing collaboration and support among teammates. The collective effort to thwart the opposition's advances creates a cohesive unit that is difficult to penetrate.


Offensive Mindset:


Concurrently, the NHL is experiencing an offensive renaissance, with league-wide scoring consistently exceeding six goals per game. Coaches are recognizing the need for players to embrace a more multifaceted approach, integrating offensive contributions into their skill set.


Offensive Contributions from All:

Coaches advocate for a cultural shift, encouraging defensive-minded players to actively participate in creating scoring opportunities. The concept of everyone contributing offensively is gaining traction, challenging players to expand their skill sets.


"Flipping the Script" Mentality:

Recognizing the importance of a mindset shift, particularly for younger players, coaches emphasize the need to "flip the script." Players, once focused solely on preventing goals, must now become active contributors to their team's offensive success.


Commanding Respect Through Scoring:

Coaches, echoing the sentiments of Buffalo Sabres head coach Don Granato, highlight the importance of scoring as a means to command respect. A team that can score effectively becomes a formidable force, forcing opponents to adjust their strategies.


Finding the Balance:


In the current era of offensive dominance, striking the right balance between defensive stability and offensive aggression is imperative for success. Coaches are steering players towards a well-rounded skill set that combines defensive responsibility with a proactive offensive mindset.



As the game of hockey evolves, players must adapt to the demands of the modern era. The once clear distinction between defensive and offensive players is blurring, giving rise to a new generation of athletes capable of influencing the game on both ends of the ice. The teams that successfully navigate this paradigm shift are likely to emerge as contenders in the dynamic and high-scoring landscape of modern hockey.


Positional Perspectives


A hockey player's mindset is often shaped, in part, by the unique demands of their positional roles on the ice.  The mindset of a player is intricately connected to the responsibilities inherent to their position.  The mindset of a player is influenced by the position they play. 


Defensive-Minded Defensemen:


Defensemen, by the nature of their role, are often perceived as the guardians of the team's defensive zone. Their mindset is deeply rooted in discipline, awareness, and a strong team-first mentality.


Discipline and Protective Instinct:

Defensemen exhibit a disciplined approach, prioritizing proper positioning and minimizing defensive breakdowns. Their mindset is often characterized by a protective instinct, where they act as a shield for the goaltender and maintain a strong defensive structure.


Awareness and Quick Reactions:

Heightened awareness and quick reactions define the defensive defenseman's mindset. Being ever-ready to intercept passes, block shots, and disrupt the opponent's offensive flow are central components of their role.


Team-First Mentality:

The team-first mentality is ingrained in the defensive defenseman's mindset. Collaboration and support among teammates, particularly in thwarting the opposition's advances, create a cohesive defensive unit.


Offensive-Minded Wingers:


Wingers, stationed on the outer edges of the offensive and defensive zones, often carry an offensive-minded mindset. Their role demands creativity, goal-scoring prowess, and a willingness to take risks.


Creativity and Goal-Scoring Instinct:

Offensive-minded wingers thrive on creativity and possess a goal-scoring instinct. Their mindset revolves around finding opportunities to outmaneuver opponents, make dynamic plays, and contribute significantly to the team's offensive output.


Willingness to Take Risks:

Wingers often exhibit a mindset that includes a degree of aggressiveness. They are willing to take calculated risks, challenge defenders one-on-one, and take shots on goal, showcasing a fearless approach to offensive play.


Balanced-Centric Centers:

Centers, positioned at the heart of the action, are typically tasked with a more balanced approach. Their mindset involves elements of both defensive responsibility and offensive creativity.


Versatility and Two-Way Play:

The mindset of a center is characterized by versatility and a commitment to two-way play. They are expected to contribute offensively while maintaining defensive responsibilities, requiring a well-rounded skill set.


Strategic Decision-Making:

Centers often possess a mindset that involves strategic decision-making. Their role as playmakers demands an understanding of when to focus on offensive contributions and when to prioritize defensive stability.



While the mindset of a player is undoubtedly shaped by various factors, including personal style and coaching philosophy, positional roles play a significant role in influencing player mentality. From the disciplined and protective mindset of defensemen to the creative and risk-taking approach of wingers, and the balanced-centric perspective of centers, the beauty of hockey lies in the diversity of mindsets that converge on the ice. Understanding these positional nuances adds depth to the appreciation of the sport, highlighting the intricate dance between offense and defense that defines the game.



Beyond Positions


A hockey player's mindsets are not solely determined by position but are also influenced by individual playing styles and the roles they are assigned within their respective lines. This article looks at  the nuanced world of hockey player mindsets, acknowledging that a player's disposition may vary within the broad categories of defensemen, wingers, and centers. Moreover, it considers the impact of specific roles, recognizing that even within these positions, players can carve out unique identities based on the demands placed upon them.


Evolving Mindsets among Defensemen


Traditionally, defensemen have been synonymous with a defensive mindset, focusing on disciplined positioning, shot blocking, and maintaining a strong team-first mentality. However, the evolving nature of the game has seen a departure from the conventional expectations placed on defensemen.


Versatility within Defense:

The modern defenseman embraces versatility, seamlessly transitioning between defensive stability and offensive creativity. Recognizing that defensive responsibilities no longer confine them, they navigate seamlessly between defensive stability and offensive creativity. This mindset shift adds a layer of unpredictability to their game, making them not only effective defenders but also potent contributors to offensive plays.


Offensive-Driven Defensemen:

Within the realm of defense, there is a growing breed of players who defy traditional norms by adopting an offensive-minded mindset. These players contribute significantly to their team's offensive output, showcasing creativity, and actively participating in goal-scoring opportunities. The once-clear line between offensive and defensive roles is becoming increasingly blurred.



Forward Flexibility: The Impact of Roles on Offensive Mindsets


Forwards, regardless of their natural inclination, can find themselves adapting to roles that demand a more defensive or checking-oriented mindset.  Furthermore regardless of if a forward is typically expected to be the primary offensive catalysts, they are not exempt from from having defensive responsibility or a checking-oriented mindset.



Checker-Role Forwards:

The third and fourth lines often feature forwards with a checker role, emphasizing defensive responsibility, physical play, and the disruption of opponents' offensive schemes. This mindset shift prioritizes shot blocking, aggressive forechecking, and maintaining a tenacious defensive presence.


Offensive Potential in Limited Roles:

Even within checking roles, forwards can exhibit surprising offensive potential. Some players seamlessly blend defensive responsibilities with goal-scoring capabilities, adding an unexpected offensive dimension to their team's repertoire. This adaptability is a testament to the versatility required of modern hockey players.


Embracing Versatility: Player Mindsets Beyond Conventions


The modern game of hockey celebrates versatility, urging players to transcend traditional expectations associated with their positions or roles.


Fluidity of Player Mindsets:

Players today embrace the fluidity of mindsets, understanding that their roles may evolve from game to game. A defensive-minded player can unleash offensive creativity, and a checker can become a goal-scoring threat.


The Impact of Coaching Philosophies:

Coaching philosophies play a pivotal role in shaping player mindsets. Coaches who encourage flexibility and creativity contribute to a team culture where players feel empowered to explore the full spectrum of their abilities.


Offensive Contributions from All:

Teams are fostering a culture that encourages offensive contributions from players in all positions. The mindset shift involves breaking away from traditional roles and recognizing that everyone, including traditionally defensive players, can actively participate in creating scoring opportunities.



As hockey continues to evolve, the rigid boundaries that once defined player mindsets are dissipating.  Player mindsets are becoming increasingly dynamic, influenced not only by traditional positional expectations but also by the demands of specific roles and the prevailing offensive strategies in the league. Defensemen are embracing offensive creativity, forwards are finding scoring potential within checking roles, and centers are navigating the delicate balance between offense and defense.  The true essence lies in a player's adaptability, versatility, and the ability to embrace the evolving demands of the game. The fluidity within player mindsets reflects the adaptability required to thrive in the modern game, where offensive dominance is the key to success.  Where roles are dynamic and expectations are fluid, players who navigate the spectrum of mindsets contribute not only to their individual success but also to the overall success of their team.




Jeff Lynt

Is a Head Scout with Elite Hockey Canada. 

Founder of EHC Agency and he is a certified Hockey Scout and Agent with SMWW - Sports Management Worldwide. jeff.lynt@elitehockeycanada.com or jlynt@smww.com

If you like this article, please share.

[See More great articles]

[Home