Febuary 20

by Jeff Lynt

With the minor hockey playoffs just around the corner, the pressure is on for coaches to lead their teams to victory. As the stakes get higher, coaches may feel the need to make strategic decisions that will give their team the best chance to win. However, one controversial practice that some minor hockey coaches resort to is shortening the bench, which involves playing only the most talented players in an effort to increase their chances of winning. While this approach may have some short-term benefits, it can have negative consequences for the development and morale of the team as a whole. 

Competitive sports, such as hockey, can bring out the best in players and coaches alike. However, the pursuit of victory can sometimes come at a cost. The shortening practice has become increasingly controversial, as it raises questions about the ethics of coaching and the impact on young players' development.  

On one hand, some coaches argue that winning is the primary goal of competitive sports, and that playing the most skilled players gives the team the best chance to win. They may also argue that this approach helps to prepare the more talented players for higher levels of competition, where they may face more pressure to perform.

However, on the other hand, many coaches, parents, and players argue that shortening the bench can have negative consequences for the players who are left on the bench. Players who don't get much playing time may become demotivated or discouraged, and they may not get the opportunity to develop their skills and improve their performance. This can be particularly detrimental for younger players who are still learning the game.

Furthermore, shortening the bench can also impact team dynamics and create a less supportive and inclusive team environment. Players who feel like they're being overlooked or undervalued may become resentful of their more talented teammates, and this can lead to a breakdown in team unity and morale.

Former NHL coach Bob Hartley once said that any minor hockey coach who shortens the bench should be kicked out of hockey. Hartley's statement highlights the strong view that some coaches and experts have on the issue of shortening the bench in minor hockey. As a former NHL coach and a well-respected figure in the hockey community, his comment emphasizes the importance of focusing on player development and the negative impact that shortening the bench can have on young players.

It's important to note that every coach has their own coaching philosophy and approach, and not all coaches agree on this issue. Some coaches may feel that winning is the most important goal, while others prioritize player development and creating a positive team environment.

However, it's essential to recognize that this is minor not professional hockey and minor hockey is about the development of all players, not just the most talented ones. It's important for coaches to recognize that every player on the team has different strengths, weaknesses, and learning styles, and they should strive to create a supportive and inclusive environment that allows every player to develop to their full potential.

While winning is certainly an important aspect of competitive sports, it should not come at the expense of player development. Coaches should view winning as a byproduct of good coaching, rather than the primary goal. This means that coaches should prioritize teaching fundamental skills, promoting teamwork, and fostering a positive learning environment for all players, regardless of their skill level.

Furthermore, every player on the team contributes to the success of the team, whether they're a star player or someone who they think shouldn't get as much ice time. By giving all players the opportunity to contribute and develop their skills, coaches can create a sense of unity and purpose within the team, which can lead to greater success in the long run.

In conclusion, coaches have a responsibility to prioritize player development over winning, and to create a positive and inclusive team environment that supports the growth and development of all players. By doing so, coaches can help young players to develop a lifelong love for the game and to achieve their full potential both on and off the ice.